For 16 years, I kept old videotapes of my late wife Nicole—precious memories meant as a gift for our daughter Amber’s 18th birthday. When I went to retrieve them, they were gone.
Nicole died in a car accident when Amber was just two. I raised her alone until I met Lauren, who became my wife five years ago. But Lauren never fully accepted Nicole’s memory.
As Amber’s birthday neared, I told Lauren about the tapes. She seemed supportive—until the next morning, when I discovered they were missing. She coldly admitted she threw them out, saying it was “time to move on.” I was devastated. Those tapes were all Amber had of her mother.
Amber returned from a school trip, and I had to break the news. She was crushed. But she insisted we try to find them. That night, we searched the city dump—and miraculously recovered four tapes.
I had them digitized. On her birthday, Amber watched her mother’s smiling face for the first time. It was emotional and healing.
When Lauren returned, her apology rang hollow. Amber couldn’t forgive her, and neither could I. Our marriage ended soon after.
Amber is now studying film, inspired by those tapes. Her latest project, Echoes, weaves her mother’s past with her own present. Watching it reminded me: love outlives loss—and no one can throw that away.