California High School Track Controversy Reignites Trans Athlete Debate
A viral moment at the CIF Southern Section Finals has reignited the national debate over transgender athletes in women’s sports. Reese Hogan of Crean Lutheran High took a stand by stepping onto the first-place podium after finishing second in the triple jump — a spot left empty after the event’s winner, transgender athlete AB Hernandez, exited.
Hernandez, who identifies as female, dominated the event with a jump over four feet ahead of Hogan and also won the long jump. Critics called the outcome unfair, while supporters say Hernandez followed all rules and deserves to compete.
The controversy echoes broader tensions. Former President Trump recently banned transgender athletes from female sports at the federal level, while some states, like Maine, refuse to adopt such bans. Past incidents, including a 2022 injury in North Carolina, have fueled efforts to restrict transgender participation in women’s sports.
Reactions online were swift and divided. Some praised Hogan’s protest; others defended Hernandez. Hernandez called the backlash “ridiculous” and noted her mixed season performance as proof she isn’t unbeatable.
Studies cited by Capital & Main suggest transgender athletes don’t consistently outperform cisgender peers, adding another layer to the heated debate.