It’s wise to stay cautious when Donald Trump makes big promises. The current president has a history of exaggeration, and many of his bold pledges have yet to materialize.
One recent promise, however, is drawing particular attention: a $2,000 dividend for nearly all Americans. Trump claims the money would come from revenue generated by his controversial tariff plan, with the payout going to all but “high income” citizens.
On Truth Social, Trump argued that tariffs are boosting the economy—citing low inflation, record markets, and rising investment—before adding: “A dividend of at least $2,000 a person (not including high income people!) will be paid to everyone.”
But the post provided no timeline or details about eligibility.
Experts immediately raised doubts. Analysts told The Guardian the plan faces two major hurdles: cost and legality. Depending on who qualifies, the payout could cost $300–$513 billion. Economist Erica York noted that tariffs have raised about $90 billion—far short of the proposed rebate.
Legal challenges add further uncertainty. Several courts have already ruled Trump’s use of emergency powers for tariffs illegal, and if the Supreme Court agrees, the funding source for the dividends vanishes.
Trump later said the payments would likely come in 2026, telling reporters: “The tariffs allow us to give a dividend… and we’re also going to be reducing debt.” Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent added that legislation would be needed.
Trump has broken many promises before, but this one could be harder for the public to overlook. Failing to deliver vague policy ideas is one thing; failing to deliver a promised $2,000 per person is another.